Decisions of V-Sekai

Title
Accepted: Better Skeleton Merge with Robust Skin Weight Transfer
Proposed: Template
Proposed: Improve the Godot Ecosystem
Proposed: Godot Engine as Wasm Importer
Proposed: Draft WebRTC Relay Test
Draft: shadermotion to BVH
Draft: View the worlds and interact with people in VR without being in VR via a Discord Inward Portal
Draft: Notify community members and users about activity and updates via a Discord bot
Accepted: Wasm Cache Incident Report
Rejected: VR Game with 80 Players and One World Server
Proposed: Can I use V-Sekai for 3d assets & 3d extensions?
Proposed: Launching the mvsqlite rdbms server
Proposed: Stress Testing Godot Engine’s Networking System
Proposed: Process the glTF2 input file and return it as is
Proposed: Enable Windows 11 Installation on Older Computers
Proposed: Workflows for 3D Model Conversion
Proposed: Stuck / Recharge Cycle
Proposed: ChatGPT-4 Based Proposal Prompt System
Accepted: Prioritizing Valve Controllers Over Meta Quest 3 Controllers
Accepted: Building a Metaverse with Glue Mechanic in V-Sekai
Proposed: Town Courier
Proposed: Implementing a 3D Previewer for GLTF with XMP Metadata
Proposed: Train quad-based Meshgpt within constraints
Proposed: Calling Open Source LLM with Aria
Proposed: Implementing a 3D Multiplayer Movement System with Parented Objects and Inventory Management
Rejected: Binding GDExtension to a C-like Language for Libgodot to Implement a Distributed Simulation
Proposed: Use Bundlex for Binding GDExtension to Elixir for Libgodot to Implement a Distributed Simulation
Proposed: Implementing Elixir Data Models for Memory, Local, Bulk, and Global Storage
Rejected: RabbitMQ RA vs SQLite on FoundationDB vs CockroachDB
Accepted: “Sunny Park” Test Case for 3D Tile Sync
Accepted: Focusing on PCVR vs Android Build vs Web Build
Proposed: Web-Based Exploration of V-Sekai
Proposed: Provide a V-Sekai Starter Kit
Proposed: Material Shader Graphic Shirt with Sharp Edges
Proposed: VRC and VRM compatibility
Accepted: k8s on harvester hci
Proposed: Hyperv windows Harvester Test
Proposed: Integrating Helm for Kubernetes Runner Installation with S3 Cache
Proposed: CI/CD Setup with Docker and Other Platforms
Proposed: Installing Helm Chart from a Git Repository using Rancher
Proposed: V-Sekai Setup as a Ready-to-Go Kit
Proposed: Teaching Large Language Models (LLMs) with Goal-Task Planners
Proposed: “Cafe Serenade” - A VR Dating Sim Experience
Proposed: for 3d Asset Schema Design and Database Backend Selection
Proposed: Synchronizing Blender and FDB-SQLite for Proxy Movement
Proposed: V-Sekai Implementation Using SLC Framework
Proposed: Real-Time Motion Capture and Animation Synchronization
Proposed: Implement Ra in V-Sekai
Proposed: V-Sekai Game Launcher
Proposed VRM mtoon in Substance Designer
Accepted: VRM Acronym Correction
Proposed: Blender to Godot API Conversion
Proposed: for using workloads to emulate the usage patterns
Proposed: Adoption of Intended Effort Versioning (EffVer) in V-Sekai
Proposed: Implementation of Essential Tuple Normalization Form (ETNF) for relational databases (rdbms, sql)
Proposed: Comprehensive Documentation for V-Sekai
Proposed: Container2Wasm Integration in V-Sekai
Proposed: Enhancing Avatar Expressiveness with AI-Generated Blend Shapes
Proposed: Urban Navigator: The City Unveiled
Proposed: Macos cicd setup.
Proposed: Elixir Livebook on Fedora 39
Proposed: Installing Tailscale on Linux Fedora 39
Proposed: Easy Diffusion AI Setup on Linux Systems
Proposed: Advanced VR Armature System for V-Sekai
Proposed: Provide Pivot Painting Resources
Proposed: Camera matching with fSpy.
Draft: Fit Clothing on Humans Without Tearing
Proposed: Magical Girls College Manager Simulator
Proposed: 1 Meter Cubed 128 Quantized
Deprecated: Valid configuration of Spatiallabs and Openxr
Proposed: Choosing a terminal emulator for Windows
Proposed: Byobu terminal multiplexer
Proposed: V-Sekai: Gateways to Virtual Worlds
Proposed: Use the “Punchline Reports” Method
Proposed: Blue Green new shadows for new avatars
Proposed: Hardsurface vs Organic
Proposed: Mesh Transformer Expressive Facial Features
Proposed: Mesh Transformer Clothing
Proposed: MaterialX try two.
Proposed: Automating Game Testing Process Using Appium 2
Proposed: Appium Testing for Windows 11
Proposed: Triangle Meshes Inferencing with MeshRWKV
Draft: Initial Training of the MeshRWVK Model
Draft: GraphSAGE Embedding Algorithm Explanation
Proposed: Seamless Integration of XR Tracking in Godot Engine
Proposed: Headless Launcher Backend with Elixir and Server-Side CockroachDB
Accepted: Benchmarking Network Performance for Scalable Multiplayer in Godot
Accepted: V-Sekai 2023-11-26 Report
Superseded: V-Sekai 2023-11-25 Report
Proposed: Upload Creative Commons FBX Test Files for Enhanced LOD Optimization in V-Sekai
Proposed: Enhancing VR Book Reading through SVG Optimization
Proposed: Defining the List of Godot Types in Elixir Godot Parsers
Proposed: Validator Service for V-Sekai
Proposed: Effective V-Sekai project archival strategy
Proposed: Evaluate AYON pipeline platform on hosted cloud services
Accepted: V-Sekai dependencies
Proposed: Efficient Training of LLMs in V-Sekai
Accepted: Overcoming the Blender T-Pose Limitation with Documentation
Proposed: Enhancing V-Sekai x Godot Engine x AYON for a Superior Workflow
Proposed: Streamlining Game Development with AI-Based Aria’s Guidance
Proposed: Character Customization Discord Bot PoC for V-Sekai
Proposed: Creation of an ‘Ask V-Sekai’ Chatbot Using Vercel, OpenAI, and Neon PostgreSQL
Proposed: PostgreSQL `bytea` Storage Optimization for V-Sekai’s Edge CDN
Proposed: “Freedom is in a future that you did not have in the past” - A Game Development Philosophy from NieR:Automata
Proposed: Development of a Community Polling Discord Bot Using Vercel and Neon PostgreSQL
Proposed: Adopting Neon for a More Manageable Backend at V-Sekai
Proposed: Adopting Neon’s Bottomless Storage with S3-Compatible Object Store for Edge CDN Data Management
Proposed: Enhancing V-Sekai Through Effective Documentation
Proposed: Ansible Server Provisioning
Proposed: PDF to SVG Conversion for VR Books
Rejected: Merge Scene Tool for Godot Editor with FlatBuffer-based JSON Serialization
Accepted: Write List of Github Pull Requests for Review
Proposed: DreamCraft3D - A Hierarchical 3D Content Generation Method
Proposed: Drawing Concept to Blockout
Proposed: Build a Cozy Apartment in VR for V-Sekai
Proposed: Solve Blender versions by locking LTS versions on Blender (3.6)
Proposed: Implementing Advanced Training Simulators in V-Sekai
Proposed: Enhancing Task-Specific Model Performance through Fine-Tuning with Axolotl
Proposed: Navigating New Horizons: A Proposal for Expanding Exploration in V-Sekai
Proposed: Llama CPP AI Model NPC
Proposed: Valve VR Ecosystem with Quest 3
Proposed: Streamlining V-Sekai Performance
Proposed: Use embedding search with Godot Engine projects
Proposed: Challenges that need to be addressed in V-Sekai
Proposed: Address Screen Resolution Compatibility Issues
Proposed: Improving xr grid with new enhancements
Draft: XPR in Elixir
Proposed: Implementing Semantic Versioning for Alpha Releases in V-Sekai
Draft: Can Poly Green Coords extend to 3d?
Draft: Translation/Transcription Badge with GGML’s Whisper
Rejected: Enabling VRM to Blender Conversion with Cloud GPUs and replicate.com
Accepted: Enhancing Map Uploads
Accepted: Fix menus in-game
Proposed: Expanding Worlds
Proposed: Improving VR Experience
Proposed: Integrating Backend Services
Proposed: OMIFest 2023 - The Call
Accepted: Use opensubdiv for level of detail
Proposed: Developing a Unified Model for Speech-to-Facial Shape Generation Using Outlines 〰 Library
Proposed: Following Tracks: Enhancing VR Train Station Simulation in V-Sekai using Godot Engine
Rejected: Rewriting Mixer Broadcaster Into Membrane Framework Pipelines
Proposed: Transitioning to Membrane Framework Pipelines with JSON-RPC Blender Runner
Proposed: Update V-Sekai game engine procedure
Proposed: Procedure to unmerge and then merge solves a V-Sekai source code broken tree
Proposed: Configuring GoCD Agents in V-Sekai
Proposed: Constrain the entire Godot Humanoid Skeleton
Accepted: Punchline based reports
Proposed: V-Sekai Navigation Compatibility with VR
Proposed: Sonic Symphony: Crafting Melodies with Machine Intelligence
Proposed: Dokku for V-Sekai URO Backend Services Hosting and Development
Accepted: Git Subrepo Addon Management
Accepted: Completing VRM 1.0 Support and Publishing to Godot Engine Asset Library
Proposed: Port Godot Jolt from GDExtension to C++ Module
Proposed: Social RPG World Proposal
Proposed: Solve Renik directly rather than through many bone ik
Proposed: Enhancing the Many Bone IK Configuration
Proposed: Game simulation server sidekick process
Proposed: Enhancing Avatar Creation Process in V-Sekai Advanced
Proposed: Enhancing Avatar Creation Process in V-Sekai Regular
Proposed: V-Sekai Feature Enhancement Proposal
Accepted: V-Sekai Meeting - Friday, June 30, 2023
Proposed: Ship Godot Engine VRM1 to solve portable humanoid avatars
Accepted: V-Sekai Roadmap and Goals 2023-06-24
Proposed: Implementing Feedback Delay Networks for Enhanced Audio Reverb Simulation in V-Sekai
Proposed: Large language model t5 generating xstate json reliabily for digital beings
Proposed: A Potential Solution for V-Sekai’s Identifier Assignment Challenge
Rejected: V-Sekai Database Solution for 50,000 Concurrent Online Users
Proposed: Networked Procedural Generation as a Sidecar to the Godot Engine Server
Accepted: V-Sekai Roadmap and Goals 2023-06-18
Proposed: V-Sekai Bone Hierarchy Conversion
Proposed: Increase variety and quality with generated animation trees
Proposed: Wasm in V-Sekai Proposal
Superseded: V-Sekai Roadmap and Goals 2023-06-08
Superseded: V-Sekai Roadmap and Goals 2023-06-02
Proposed: Pmx module integration
Proposed: Capturing accurate body movements with limited tracker placement
Proposed: Propose a solution to improve V-Sekai contributors’ design skills for navigating 3D environments
Proposed: Build a Single-Instance MacOS Editor for the iPad
Superseded: V-Sekai Roadmap and Goals 2023-05-19
Proposed: Efficiently managing and synchronizing game data with a server sidecar
Proposed: Implement server-side content validation export followed by a sanitization service and CDN support
Proposed: Generating Random Text Data for testing V-Sekai systems
Proposed: Handling access to session based game data
Draft: Finding ways to attract users, developers, and creators sustaining V-Sekai
Proposed: Create a 12x12 meter 3D demo map with 2-meter-high obstacles and walls
Proposed: Convert IK solvers to be using the AnimationTree
Draft: Improve V-Sekai marketing
Rejected: Defeating your fictional enemies in their blood
Proposed: Improving Jitter-Buffer Implementation for Voice Chat in V-Sekai Projects
Superseded: V-Sekai Roadmap and Goals 2023-05-19
Proposed: Add VRM portable avatars and OMI_personality to the GLTF Transform tool
Superseded: V-Sekai Roadmap and Goals 2023-05-16
Accepted: Aquarium Nightclub Booth for Virtual Market Exhibition
Rejected: Additional 3D Import Functionality
Draft: Exchange data between Godot Engine and WASM using handles
Draft: Convert segmented front facing 3D Garment images to novel 3d views for 3d modeling
Rejected: Using Deno to handle the conversion of GLB files to Godot Engine packed scenes
Rejected: Distributed simulation
Draft: Describe a avatar publishing workflow for portability
Superseded: Solve V-Sekai limitations using ChatGPT-4 AI completion.
Proposed: VR design application for V-Sekai
Proposed: Enhancing Cross-Platform Compatibility and User Experience for V-Sekai VR Social Players
Proposed: Solve a V-Sekai naming convention limitation.
Proposed: Automated avatar garment rigging
Accepted: Adding IREE to Godot Engine for Image Superresolution
Superseded: V-Sekai Roadmap and Goals 2023-04-20
Proposed: Improve the collaboration process and attract more contributors to work on the project
Accepted: Challenges in managing and synchronizing multiple assets and libraries across different git repositories
Rejected: Package Godot for pkgin
Proposed: Capturing accurate body movements with limited tracker placement
Proposed: Use godot rgbaf textures to store integers
Proposed: Procedurally create variations for our props, environments and avatars
Proposed: Hit a collaborate button to load up into V-Sekai
Proposed: Provide v-sekai-game in a launcher to make it easier to use v-sekai
Proposed: Use junit xml based tests in github
Proposed: Don’t merge incomplete work.
Superseded: Creating a Godot Engine C++ module with IREE backend for machine learning computations using Vulkan and CUDA
Accepted: Meet at GDC SF 2023
Accepted: Default test plan for testing V-Sekai engine upgrades.
Proposed: Adopt best practices for product development
Proposed: Without visualization, we cannot easily compare the interpolation states
Proposed: Provide user generated scripting with libsql and wasm
Proposed: Have two groups move towards each other battle demo
Proposed: Provide metadata to pre-check if maps and avatars are compatible to load
Proposed: Possible futures
Proposed: Grow the community with a reactive Discord bot.
Proposed: Create an in-game tablet interface we can activate
Proposed: Cover 80% to 95% of the player base.
Proposed: Use Easy Charts for observability
Proposed: Recording demo checklist
Proposed: Ready net demo
Proposed: Publish Godot VRM for Godot 4 for production use
Proposed: Provide user generated scripting using WasGO
Proposed: No traversal loading screen
Proposed: Better Godot Engine integration with Blender with gltf extensions
Proposed: Face helmet capture
Proposed: Add WMF for windows media playback
Accepted: Bolster creating the metaverse
Accepted: How to start a EXPERIMENTAL environment for sqlite and elixir?
Accepted: Separate walking controller from RenIK for ManyBoneIK
Proposed: Powershell autocomplete uses right arrow
Proposed: Tools helpful for creating Avatars and Worlds
Proposed: Prepare godot-vrm for asset library publishing
Proposed: Port RENIK to Many Bone IK for better quality
Proposed: Move fast without breaking things for V-Sekai
Proposed: Debug Linux Export
Proposed: Target 10 minutes cicd builds to improve our iterations
Rejected: Blocking direct push to MAIN to avoid build breakage
Draft: Simulate larger 3d multiplayer worlds using “brickworlds partition layout”
Proposed: Make it easier to propose and file bugs by simplifying the templates
Proposed: Replicate sync 100’000 entities using a solution (Revision 1)
Proposed: Networking with 100000 Entities and Ownership (Revision 2)
Proposed: Replicate sync 100’000 entities using Godot Engine, mvsqlite and Foundationdb
Proposed: To remember how to update the engine and game write a procedure
Rejected: Use view replication algorithm for multiplayer multirelay sync
Draft: Networking Overhaul
Proposed: Unidot is optional
Proposed: Rename master to godot3 and main to godot4
Proposed: We have too many branches on V-Sekai/godot.
Proposed: Extended asset library packages in addition to the upstream asset library
Proposed: Provide pdf reading
Proposed: Make a market booth creation tutorial.
Proposed: Simulate cloth on characters
Proposed: Bake alembic imports by running blender script.
Proposed: Connect Mediapipe to Blender
Proposed: Host a baserow application for internal use.
Accepted: To avoid git submodule but recreate the gocd pipelines
Proposed: Lightweight quality avatars
Rejected: To create a deployment kit use truescale to host gocd agents for cicd.
Accepted: How to start a development environment for cockroach and elixir?
Proposed: Profile using perf
Proposed: Merge retargeting feature into Godot Engine master
Proposed: Use specular vec3 from gltf to show multicoloured metals
Proposed: To protect the minimum spec maintain steam deck version of flatmode V-Sekai
Draft: To provide an asset library prototype use baserow
Accepted: Planning V-Sekai Version 3 on 2022-02-28
Superseded: Planning V-Sekai Version 2 on 2022-02-24
Rejected: Storing raw VSK_map files via DVC to avoid limitations
Accepted: Rank skeleton #bone names with catboost
Accepted: Rank skeleton #bone names with xgboost
Accepted: Rank skeleton #bone names with transformer4rec
Superseded: Planning V-Sekai on 2022-02-21 Superseded
Accepted: To create omi chan rig a #256FES
Proposed: To deploy backend services like Uro safely use a defined process
Accepted: To make a virtual pet game given Jeana’s designs
Proposed: Log change notifications using DiscordChatExporter
Accepted: Allow cicd to pass by fixing spatial audio branch
Draft: To have a default set of motions on a 3d character by creating a default animation set
Accepted: Interoperability between platforms using gltf extensions
Rejected: To allow independent deployment run our own infrastructure
Accepted: To have an alternative CICD use Github Actions.
Proposed: Make a desktop version of Uro for ease of development.
Accepted: To record decisions write a proposal.
Proposal: Optimize cicd for costs because it’s limited
Accepted: To make it easier to upload V-Sekai maps and Avatars use Godot Engine 4 script templates.
Accepted: Convert gltf to a scene with AudioStreamPlayer3D, convert AudiostreamPlayer3D to gltf and expose usability.
Proposal: Change transform by CRDT.
Proposal: Bake blend shapes to skeletons for performance
Proposal: Stream a character from a webcam to the vmc protocol
Accepted: Run meetings using Lean Coffee
Rejected: Network the Ubisoft Mixer server
Accepted: Create an open metaverse by working on V-Sekai
Rejected: Create Steamdeck hardware proxy by installing Fedora Silverblue and #steam
Rejected: Create Steamdeck hardware proxy by installing Fedora Kinoite and #steam
Accepted: For Godot Engine changes use a decision flowchart
Accepted: Create an upstream pull request for all non-V-Sekai related patches
Accepted: Avoid avatar breaking by following quality checklist
Accepted: Create a Godot Engine asset store service on elixir and on sqlite.
Accepted: Stabilize Godot Engine updates by delaying to 2 week cycles
Proposed: Allow Godot Asset Library browser to use alternative sources
Proposed: Learn how to scale V-Sekai using bots and multipliers
Rejected: File or attestation for virtual worlds using ssh signatures
Accepted: Degrade V-Sekai’s networking model to work in 2d and with webrtc.
Draft: Create a VRM character by experimenting with written workflows.
Proposed: Polish demo of V-Sekai by making invisible meshes appear via the use of the exporter.
Proposed: Integrate with blender
Draft: Preview #materialx materials on the Web in Godot Engine
Draft: Use single player WebXR in Godot Engine to prototype CASSIE.
Accepted: Take a list of 3D points that form a vaguely closed boundary in space and triangulate in Godot Engine
Rejected: Iterate faster on WasGo prototype by using Godot 3.4
Rejected: Have an WebXR version of V-Sekai that is more accessible
Draft: Research mesh tooling with nglod
Draft: Research mesh tooling with kaolin
Draft: Use a standard reference platform called VFX Reference platform
Accepted: VOIP
Draft: VMD on VRM AnimationTree Node
Draft: Verification tools
Accepted: Use our custom fullbody IK
Proposed: Rank skeleton bone names by using BPR
Proposed: Update URO for Godot 4
Proposed: Tire model car sim
Accepted: ThorVG
Proposed: Take a streaming godot game and streaming the VRM to OpenSoundControl
Proposed: Stream shader motion
Proposed: Standard backup procedures
Proposed: To provide a performance and portable script use WasGo
Proposed: Run the maintenance scripts from Windows in Unix mode with msys2
Superseded: Play preprocessed #animation on any VRM model
Proposed: Plausible npc behavior
Proposed: Phase out groups in the branding to make it more recognizable
Rejected: OpenVR for Godot Engine
Proposed: Membrane Framework streaming Mixer
Proposed: Meeting area
Proposed: Make a place to record
Accepted: Keep a changelog
Proposed: How to make a V-Sekai/godot update?
Proposed: Have wires in 3d
Proposed: Have better user developer experience
Proposed: Godot Database viewer for proposals
Proposed: glTF - importer should bind animation players to the closest root node
Proposed: Face motion tracking requires standard shapes
Proposed: Extract proposals into proposals
Proposed: Export / Import testing via robot-framework and swiftshader
Proposed: Create a demo viewer gallery
Proposed: Construct the virtual #world
Proposed: Client and Mast
Proposed: CICD Export V-Sekai
Proposed: Character workshop
Proposed: Benchmark #animation playback
Proposed: Bake blend shape to skeleton animation
Proposed: Bake a #materialx into a custom Godot StandardMaterial3D
Proposed: ARC radial menu
Proposed: 1000 player servers
Proposed: We want to proxy udp datagrams at production quality of service.
Proposed: Want to use the same cluster for the same web and native.
Proposed: Summon #friend and acquaintances via presence to the current world.
Proposed: Use materialx for asset interchange
Proposed: Use KVM to test our AMD APU test computer via Barrier.
Proposed: Test Google Mediapipe
Proposed: Solve Mocap By Connecting Mediapipe to Blender
Proposed: Improve Meshing Results by Subdivision in Godot Engine
Proposed: Create SOP for VRM #creation
Proposed: Create a standard procedure from adding spring bones to VRM models.
Proposed: Music is important to human experience and should be bridged to XR
Proposed: Spoke to V-Sekai
Proposed: Soiree party mode
Proposed: OMI Glb Portable Content
Proposed: Neural Blend Shape Rigging
Proposed: Import Minecraft worlds to Godot Engine
Proposed: Minimum Specification V-Sekai Hardware
Accepted: OIT in Godot Engine
Proposed: GLB data in a Movie
Proposed: Membrane Framework to Process Game Workflows
Proposed: Godot Engine implementation of disconnected IPFS
Proposed: Spreadsheet Animation Preview
Proposed: Portable #world Content
Proposed: Material Addon Blender
Proposed: Describe a Godot Engine pr verification workflow
Proposed: Transfer animation by baking reset
Proposed: Convert #shadermotion to be played in Godot Engine
Proposed: Convert FBX and glTF2 to VRM via flow-avatar-asset-pipeline
Proposed: Store presentation and book content via Lottie
Proposed: Performance profile the game with AMDuProf
Proposed: Trial install of Gravity for Kubernetes
Proposed: Simplify Meshes and LODs better with Quads
Proposed: Retarget VRM Motion Blender Workflow
Proposed: Distribute trusted clients with notary
Accepted: Complete glTF2 / VRM import and export pipeline in Godot Engine
Accepted: Support more flexible texture import via Basis Universal in Godot Engine
Accepted: Use Markdown Architectural Decision Records
Superseded: Use Log4brains to manage the ADRs
Proposed: Add build notifications
Accepted: Adding Entity Networking to Groups
Accepted: Manage backend resources on one or more physical machines with K3S