Proposed: Adopting Neon’s Bottomless Storage with S3-Compatible Object Store for Edge CDN Data Management

Metadata

Status: Proposed
Deciders: V-Sekai, Fire
Tags: V-Sekai, Neon, Edge Hosting, Bottomless Storage, S3 Compatible, CDN, PostgreSQL, bytea

The Backdrop

V-Sekai operates an open-source platform and is in need of a scalable, high-performance solution for storing and managing CDN data for avatars and worlds at the edge.

The Challenge

How can V-Sekai effectively use Neon’s bottomless storage, which leverages PostgreSQL’s capabilities and an S3-compatible object store, for edge-hosted CDN data management?

The Strategy

Implement an edge computing architecture with Neon’s PostgreSQL services, employing the bytea data type for binary data storage and Neon’s bottomless storage system for flushing PostgreSQL pages to an S3-compatible object store.

The Upside

Edge-hosted architecture for optimal performance and data sovereignty.
S3-compatible storage enables cost-effective scaling and redundancy.
The use of PostgreSQL’s bytea accommodates efficient binary data management without special maintenance.

The Downside

bytea data type has a 1GB size limit and requires loading full data into memory for operations, which might affect performance with large objects.
Dependence on the reliability of S3-compatible services at the edge.

The Road Not Taken

Centralized or non-S3-compatible storage solutions that may not provide the latency and scalability benefits of an edge-hosted environment.

The Infrequent Use Case

Cases where binary data exceeds the bytea size limit, necessitating additional strategies for data segmentation or alternative storage methods.

In Core and Done by Us?

Yes, the edge-hosted Neon infrastructure with an S3-compatible object store is planned to be developed and maintained in-house as a core component of V-Sekai’s backend.